qemu /
qemu /
056c5c90c171c4895b407af0cf3d198e1d44b40f Revert "target/arm: Fix usage of MMU indexes when EL3 is AArch32"
This reverts commit 4c2c0474693229c1f533239bb983495c5427784d.
This commit tried to fix a problem with our usage of MMU indexes when
EL3 is AArch32, using what it described as a "more complicated
approach" where we share the same MMU index values for Secure PL1&0
and NonSecure PL1&0. In theory this should work, but the change
didn't account for (at least) two things:
(1) The design change means we need to flush the TLBs at any point
where the CPU state flips from one to the other. We already flush
the TLB when SCR.NS is changed, but we don't flush the TLB when we
take an exception from NS PL1&0 into Mon or when we return from Mon
to NS PL1&0, and the commit didn't add any code to do that.
(2) The ATS12NS* address translate instructions allow Mon code (which
is Secure) to do a stage 1+2 page table walk for NS. I thought this
was OK because do_ats_write() does a page table walk which doesn't
use the TLBs, so because it can pass both the MMU index and also an
ARMSecuritySpace argument we can tell the table walk that we want NS
stage1+2, not S. But that means that all the code within the ptw
that needs to find e.g. the regime EL cannot do so only with an
mmu_idx -- all these functions like regime_sctlr(), regime_el(), etc
would need to pass both an mmu_idx and the security_space, so they
can tell whether this is a translation regime controlled by EL1 or
EL3 (and so whether to look at SCTLR.S or SCTLR.NS, etc).
In particular, because regime_el() wasn't updated to look at the
ARMSecuritySpace it would return 1 even when the CPU was in Monitor
mode (and the controlling EL is 3). This meant that page table walks
in Monitor mode would look at the wrong SCTLR, TCR, etc and would
generally fault when they should not.
Rather than trying to make the complicated changes needed to rescue
the design of 4c2c04746932, we revert it in order to instead take the
route that that commit describes as "the most straightforward" fix,
where we add new MMU indexes EL30_0, EL30_3, EL30_3_PAN to correspond
to "Secure PL1&0 at PL0", "Secure PL1&0 at PL1", and "Secure PL1&0 at
PL1 with PAN".
This revert will re-expose the "spurious alignment faults in
Secure PL0" issue #2326; we'll fix it again in the next commit.
Cc: qemu-stable@nongnu.org
Signed-off-by: Peter Maydell <peter.maydell@linaro.org>
Tested-by: Thomas Huth <thuth@redhat.com>
Message-id: 20241101142845.1712482-2-peter.maydell@linaro.org
Reviewed-by: Richard Henderson <richard.henderson@linaro.org>
8 files changed
